Use allspice in savory sides and discover a whole new world of flavor possibilities. A simple mushroom medley transforms into a spice bazaar with this one simple addition. Allspice is an all-in-one spice. It has warm, sweet notes of cinnamon and nutmeg and zingy notes of ginger and clove. These play wonderfully with the woodsy flavor of the mushrooms. For this recipe, we used a few different types of mushrooms for contrast in texture and flavor, including local chanterelles and lobster mushrooms, but the flavors shine with any combination. Try crimini, shiitake, portobello or your local favorite. The amount of allspice used in this recipe is generous and flavorful, a traditional measure in Mediterranean and Middle Eastern cuisine. This flavorful medley is wonderful on a steak, makes an exotic holiday side dish or appetizer on toast.
Allspice Mushroom Medley

Use allspice in savory sides and discover a whole new world of flavor possibilities. A simple mushroom medley transforms into a spice bazaar with this one simple addition. Allspice is an all-in-one spice. It has warm, sweet notes of cinnamon and nutmeg and zingy notes of ginger and clove. These play wonderfully with the woodsy flavor of the mushrooms. For this recipe, we used a few different types of mushrooms for contrast in texture and flavor, including local chanterelles and lobster mushrooms, but the flavors shine with any combination. Try crimini, shiitake, portobello or your local favorite. The amount of allspice used in this recipe is generous and flavorful, a traditional measure in Mediterranean and Middle Eastern cuisine. This flavorful medley is wonderful on a steak, makes an exotic holiday side dish or appetizer on toast.

Use allspice in savory sides and discover a whole new world of flavor possibilities. A simple mushroom medley transforms into a spice bazaar with this one simple addition. Allspice is an all-in-one spice. It has warm, sweet notes of cinnamon and nutmeg and zingy notes of ginger and clove. These play wonderfully with the woodsy flavor of the mushrooms. For this recipe, we used a few different types of mushrooms for contrast in texture and flavor, including local chanterelles and lobster mushrooms, but the flavors shine with any combination. Try crimini, shiitake, portobello or your local favorite. The amount of allspice used in this recipe is generous and flavorful, a traditional measure in Mediterranean and Middle Eastern cuisine. This flavorful medley is wonderful on a steak, makes an exotic holiday side dish or appetizer on toast.
Ingredients
For the Mushrooms:
- 1-1/2 pounds mixed mushrooms, roughly chopped
- 1 tablespoon olive oil
- 1-1/2 tablespoons butter, divided
- 1-1/2 teaspoons ground Allspice - JamaicanAllspice - JamaicanThis single-origin allspice berry from Jamaica is a delicious find. The flavors are more vibrant than those from other origins, with a greater intensity all around. The flavors of cl...
- 1/2 teaspoon Peppercorn - Black - VietnamesePeppercorn - Black - VietnameseVietnamese black pepper has a delightful flavor- peppery as pepper should be with a fresh layer of flavor on top. This peppercorn has a mellow complexity, with all kinds of playful f...
- 1 teaspoon Diamond Crystal - Kosher SaltDiamond Crystal - Kosher SaltDiamond Crystal is our go-to all purpose kosher salt. Developed in 1886 using a special process which creates a unique, hollow, multi-faceted crystals, this all-purpose salt is free ...
- 1 small shallot, minced
- 2 garlic cloves, minced
- 2 tablespoons dry white wine
- 1 tablespoon butter
For the Garnish:
- Chopped parsley
Preparation
Preheat a medium sauté pan on medium-high heat. Add the olive oil and 1 tablespoon of butter. Heat until the butter is melted then add the mushrooms. Cook 2-4 minutes, stirring only occasionally, so they become lightly golden brown.
Next add the shallot, garlic and spices. Sauté until the shallot is soft and fragrant, 2-4 minutes more.
When the mushrooms are tender and cooked through, deglaze the pan with the white wine and finish with chopped parsley and an additional dab of butter.
Serve hot as a side or on toast.
Comments
Maryellen Lewis
Problem: Some of your recipes (like this one) won't allow me to Forward them to myself via email, so I could put them into my Recipes folder. Can you fix this?
Porter Bayne
Thank you for the comment. How are you forwarding the recipe to yourself? Are you in an email, or reading it on this website?
Allspice Mushroom Medley
| Appetizers, Side Dishes, Brunch
Use allspice in savory sides and discover a whole new world of flavor possibilities. A simple mushroom medley transforms into a spice bazaar with this one simple addition. Allspice is an all-in-one spice. It has warm, sweet notes of cinnamon and nutmeg and zingy notes of ginger and clove. These play wonderfully with the woodsy flavor of the mushrooms. For this recipe, we used a few different types of mushrooms for contrast in texture and flavor, including local chanterelles and lobster mushrooms, but the flavors shine with any combination. Try crimini, shiitake, portobello or your local favorite. The amount of allspice used in this recipe is generous and flavorful, a traditional measure in Mediterranean and Middle Eastern cuisine. This flavorful medley is wonderful on a steak, makes an exotic holiday side dish or appetizer on toast.
Jamie Aragonez
Jamie Aragonez